Trial Law: Tiger's Loss Offers Good Lesson

Tiger Woods is the greatest golfer of his time. He was such a lock going into the weekend of the PGA Championship that an Irish bookmaker actually paid out the winnings on Tiger before the third round even started -- oops! I'll admit that I never could have imagined Y.E. Yang would actually pull it out for a victory.

But all of this provides a good lesson about trial law. You just never know what will happen when you go in front of a jury or judge. The case you thought was a lock may not be so.  When we are in the role of representing the underdog (which is often the case) I love it when the other side says we can't win. It motivates us, and frankly, it takes much of the pressure off. If you're not supposed to win you have nowhere to go but up!

So thanks, Y.E.. You proved why the game must be played, no matter who is in the lead (or who thinks they have the case that can't be beat).

 

 

 

Repeat After Me: Get it in Writing

A recent case reported in the Des Moines Register discusses how a handshake deal on the sale of a home went awry for a man that apparently invested over $100,000 in a home - only to learn the home was not his.

Actually there was a one-line agreement in this instance which read, "I Floyd A. Schake agree to put 1500 E. 9th on contract with Billy Erico Stockbauer on 1 Feb. 1989." Schake argued successfully to the court that the language meant he intended to sell the home on contract in the future but the deal was never made.

While the axiom is to get a contract in writing, it is especially critical in real estate deals where oral contracts are generally not valid. The judge in the case ruled that the language did not set out the terms necessary to convey the property.  It's fairly easy to criticize Stockbauer for not having an agreement that set out all the terms but this type of thing happens much more than anyone would ever imagine.

That's why the old adage holds, "get it in writing."