1722790268-2814-4354-lxb_photofzOITuS1DIQlxb_photo-
JESHOOTS.COM, Unsplash

Running a business comes with a myriad of challenges, and among the most daunting are the legal hurdles that can arise at various stages of the business lifecycle. As a business lawyer, these are some of the common legal struggles I often see business owners face:

1. Business Formation and Structure

Choosing the right business structure is crucial for legal and financial success. Business owners often struggle with deciding whether to form a sole proprietorship, partnership, LLC, or corporation. Each structure has different implications for liability, taxation, and management. There’s a LOT of information out there on Internet. Don’t try to make the decision on your own. Reach out to a business lawyer and accountant to help you make the determination.

2. Compliance with Regulations

Businesses must adhere to a multitude of federal, state, and local regulations. Compliance can be complex, involving areas such as employment laws, health and safety regulations, environmental laws, and industry-specific standards. Non-compliance can result in significant penalties. Understanding the regulations that impact your business will start you on the right foot.

3. Intellectual Property Protection

Protecting intellectual property (IP) is vital for maintaining a competitive edge. Business owners need to secure patents, trademarks, copyrights, and trade secrets to safeguard their innovations and brand identity. Failure to protect IP can lead to costly legal disputes. It starts as early as choosing your business name. Consult with a business and IP lawyer to avoid a trademark infringement claim.

4. Contracts and Agreements

Drafting, reviewing, and negotiating contracts is a routine but critical task for business owners. Properly crafted contracts are essential to protect business interests, define relationships with partners, clients, and suppliers, and mitigate risks. Want your attorneys’ fees paid for if you need to file a claim against a customer for non-payment? You better have that provision in your contract, otherwise you likely won’t be able to make that claim.

5. Employment Law Issues

Employment law is a complex area that covers hiring practices, employee rights, wage and hour laws, workplace safety, and termination procedures. Business owners must navigate these laws to avoid disputes and potential lawsuits. Draft an employment handbook in the early stages of your business.

6. Dispute Resolution

Conflicts are inevitable in business. Whether it’s disputes with customers, suppliers, or business partners, having effective strategies for dispute resolution—such as negotiation, mediation, arbitration or litigation—is crucial for minimizing disruptions.

7. Taxation Issues

Understanding and managing tax obligations is a significant challenge. Business owners must comply with various tax laws and regulations, including income tax, payroll tax, sales tax, and other local taxes. Missteps in tax compliance can lead to severe financial penalties. Also, consult with an accountant to determine the ideal legal structure to minimize tax and maximize deductions.

8. Data Privacy and Cybersecurity

With increasing reliance on digital technologies, protecting sensitive data and ensuring cybersecurity is paramount. Businesses must comply with data protection laws and implement robust cybersecurity measures to protect against breaches. Regularly security protocols and conducting employee training on cyber security best practices can further enhance your defense against potential threats.

9. Licensing and Permits

Many businesses require specific licenses and permits to operate legally. Navigating the application process and maintaining compliance with licensing requirements can be challenging, especially for highly regulated industries.

10. Mergers and Acquisitions

Mergers and acquisitions (M&A) present unique legal challenges, including due diligence, valuation, negotiation, and integration. Legal counsel is essential to ensure that the transaction is structured properly and all legal requirements are met.

11. Succession Planning

Planning for the future transition of business ownership is critical for long-term success. Business owners need to develop a succession plan that addresses leadership continuity, ownership transfer, and potential tax implications. Want to sell your business? Consult with a business lawyer prior to entering into negotiations with a buyer.

Conclusion

Navigating the legal landscape is a complex and ongoing process for business owners. By understanding and proactively addressing these common legal struggles, business owners can better protect their interests and ensure long-term success. As a business lawyer, I help my clients with these challenges and provide strategic legal guidance to help you thrive in a competitive and ever-changing environment.

1722800369-2824-8737-lxb_photowNxbeoNUg_4lxb_photo-
Annika Wischnewsky, Unsplash

Contracts. The word alone might make you think of stacks of paper and endless legal jargon. But fear not! As your friendly Iowa business lawyer, I am here to break down the basics of contracts. By the end of this post, you’ll feel more confident in understanding the backbone of every business deal. Let’s dive in!

1. The Offer: The Starting Point of Every Deal

Imagine you are at a lemonade stand. You offer to buy a cup of lemonade for $1. That’s the offer – the starting point of your contract. In legal terms, an offer is a promise to do or refrain from doing something in exchange for something else (usually money). The offer needs to be clear, definite, and communicated to the other party. So, when you say, “I’ll buy this lemonade for $1,” you are laying down the first brick of your contract.

2. Acceptance: Sealing the Deal

Next, the guy at the lemonade stand says, “Deal!” That’s acceptance. In the contract world, acceptance means agreeing to the terms of the offer without any changes. It must be communicated back to the person who made the offer. Just like saying “Deal!” in our lemonade stand story, acceptance transforms the offer into a binding agreement.

3. Consideration: The Value Exchanged in the Contract

Consideration is what makes the world of contracts go round. It’s the value exchanged between parties. In our lemonade stand example, your $1 is the consideration for the lemonade, and the lemonade is the consideration for your $1. Both parties must provide something of value for a contract to be enforceable. Without consideration, a contract is just a promise, not a legally binding agreement.

4. Mutuality of Obligation: The Balance of Promises

Contracts are a two-way street. Mutuality of obligation means both parties must be bound to perform their promises, or neither is bound. Imagine if you promised to pay $1, but the guy didn’t promise to give you lemonade in return, that wouldn’t work! Both parties need to have obligations they must fulfill.

5. Competency and Capacity: The Legal Power to Contract

Both parties entering into a contract must have the legal capacity to do so. This means they understand what they are agreeing to and have the legal authority to enter into a contract. For instance, if it’s a 10-year-old selling the lemonade, the kid might not have the legal capacity to enter into the contract. A kid selling lemonade must also have the capacity to sell. Generally, you must be at least 18 years of age and have your mental faculties in order to contract in Iowa.

6. Legality of Purpose: Keeping it Above Board

Last but not least, the purpose of the contract must be legal. You cannot enforce a contract to do something illegal, like selling prohibited items. Our lemonade stand contract works because selling lemonade is legal (and refreshing) on hot Iowa summer days.

Why Understanding Contracts Matters

Whether you are running a lemonade stand or a multinational corporation, understanding the basics of contracts can help you navigate business dealings with confidence and ease. Contracts ensure that everyone knows their obligations and rights, reducing the risk of disputes and fostering smoother business relationships.

Final Thoughts

Contracts do not have to be intimidating. With a basic understanding of offers, acceptance, consideration, and the other essential elements, you are well on your way to mastering the art of contracts. The next time you find yourself making a deal, remember these fundamentals, and you will begin to navigate the world of contracts like a pro!

When considering buying a franchise, one factor stands out as particularly critical to your success: franchisor support. Franchisor support can make or break your franchise journey, providing the necessary guidance, resources, and assistance to help you thrive. Here’s how to effectively assess the level and quality of support offered by a franchisor.

1. Review the Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD)

Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD): This document provides detailed information about the franchise system, including the support services offered by the franchisor. Pay special attention to:

  • Item 11: This section outlines the franchisor’s obligations regarding initial and ongoing support, including training programs, advertising, computer systems, and other operational assistance.

2. Evaluate Training Programs

Initial Training:

  • Scope and Duration: Assess the completeness of the initial training program. It should cover all essential aspects of running the franchise, such as operations, marketing, customer service, and management.
  • Location and Format: Determine where the training takes place and whether it includes both classroom instruction and hands-on experience. Does the franchisor come to your location for the grand opening and for a portion of your start up period?

Ongoing Training:

  • Continued Education: Look for opportunities for ongoing training, such as webinars, workshops, conferences, and additional courses that keep you updated on industry trends and new practices.
  • Support Materials: Check if the franchisor provides updated manuals, guides, and other materials to assist with ongoing operations.

3. Investigate Marketing and Advertising Support

Marketing Plan:

  • National and Local Strategies: Review the franchisor’s marketing plan to understand the types of marketing and advertising support provided. This could include national advertising campaigns, local marketing strategies, and online/social media marketing assistance.
  • Advertising Fund: Determine if there is a national or regional advertising fund, and understand how your contributions are utilized to benefit your franchise. Understand the costs involved.

4. Analyze Operational Support

Field Support:

  • Regional Managers: Find out if the franchisor provides field support through regional managers or consultants who visit your location regularly to offer guidance and assistance.
  • On-Site Visits: Assess the frequency and quality of on-site visits to help address operational challenges and improve business performance.

Help Desk:

  • 24/7 Assistance: Check if there is a dedicated help desk or support hotline available for franchisees to get immediate assistance with operational issues.
  • Response Time: Inquire about the average response time and effectiveness of the support team in resolving issues. Does the franchisor respond to emails and phone calls?

5. Talk to Current and Former Franchisees

Current Franchisees:

  • Firsthand Insights: Reach out to current franchisees to gather insights into their experiences with franchisor support. Ask specific questions about the quality and timeliness of training, marketing, and operational assistance. Make sure especially to talk with franchisees in your region as experiences can vary across the country in different regions. Ask them: would they do it again?
  • Challenges and Successes: Learn about any challenges they faced and how the franchisor helped them overcome these obstacles.

Former Franchisees:

  • Reasons for Leaving: If possible, speak with former franchisees to understand why they left the system and their views on the support they received. This can provide valuable context about potential issues within the franchise system.

6. Visit Franchise Locations

Observation:

  • Operational Standards: Visit several franchise locations to observe operations firsthand. This can give you a sense of how well the franchise system operates and the level of support provided by the franchisor.
  • Discussions: Use these visits as an opportunity to discuss with franchisees their experiences and the quality of support they receive. Don’t just drop in though. Schedule a time to visit so you respect their time.

7. Assess Technology and Systems Support

POS and Management Systems:

  • Technology Integration: Evaluate the technology and systems provided by the franchisor, such as point-of-sale (POS) systems, inventory management, and customer relationship management (CRM) systems.
  • Technical Support: Ensure that there is adequate technical support available to help you manage and troubleshoot these systems.

8. Evaluate the Franchisor’s Commitment to Innovation

Product and Service Development:

  • Continuous Improvement: Assess the franchisor’s commitment to continuous improvement and innovation in their products or services. This shows their dedication to staying competitive in the market.
  • Adaptability: Determine how the franchisor responds to market changes and supports franchisees in implementing new practices or products.

9. Review Financial Performance Representations

Item 19: If the franchisor includes financial performance representations in Item 19 of the FDD, analyze these representations to understand the potential profitability and revenue expectations. This can give you an idea of the financial support and potential you can expect. Talk with an accountant regarding these financial representations.

10. Seek Legal and Professional Advice

Legal Review:

  • Franchise Attorney: Have a franchise attorney review the FDD and franchise agreement to ensure you fully understand the support obligations of the franchisor and your rights as a franchisee. Work to fully understand what it actually means to be a franchisee.

Professional Consultation:

  • Accountants and Consultants: Consult with accountants or franchise consultants who can provide an objective assessment of the franchisor’s support system. Their expertise can help you make a more informed decision.

Assessing franchisor support is a crucial step in choosing the right franchise. By thoroughly evaluating training programs, marketing assistance, operational support, and speaking with current and former franchisees, you can gain a clear understanding of the support you will receive. This due diligence will help you make an informed decision and set you up for success in your franchise journey.

A twenty-four year old woman counting dollar bills.
Alexander Grey, Unsplash

Buying an existing business can be a fantastic way to become an entrepreneur without starting from scratch. However, it requires careful planning, evaluation, and execution. Here are some essential tips and strategies to guide you through the process.

1. Evaluate Financial, Market, and Operational Strength

Financial Evaluation:

  • Review Financial Statements: Analyze the balance sheets, income statements, and cash flow statements of the business for at least the past three years.
  • Profitability: Determine the business’s profitability trends. Look for consistent profits or a solid growth trend.
  • Debt and Liabilities: Assess any outstanding debts and liabilities. Understand the debt structure and payment schedules.
  • Cash Flow: Evaluate the cash flow of the business to ensure it can cover operating expenses and potential new debt from the purchase.

Market Evaluation:

  • Market Position: Understand how the business is positioned within its market. Is it a market leader, or does it struggle to compete?
  • Customer Base: Analyze the customer base for diversity and loyalty. A concentrated customer base can be risky. Better to have a wide variety of customers to reduce risk.
  • Market Trends: Research industry trends to ensure the business has growth potential in a stable or expanding market. Watch out for fads.

Operational Evaluation:

  • Business Model: Understand the business model and how it generates revenue. Ensure it aligns with your skills and interests.
  • Operational Processes: Review the operational processes and identify any inefficiencies or areas for improvement. Is is a business that has not been modernized? If not, that can often present a great opportunity for a buyer.
  • Employees and Management: Assess the skills and stability of the current employees and management team. Employee turnover can be a red flag.

2. Perform Due Diligence on Legal and Tax Documents

Legal Due Diligence:

  • Contracts and Agreements: Examine all contracts and agreements, including leases, vendor agreements, and customer contracts.
  • Intellectual Property: Verify ownership of patents, trademarks, copyrights, and any other intellectual property.
  • Litigation: Check for any ongoing or past litigation involving the business.

Tax Due Diligence:

  • Tax Returns: Review tax returns for at least the last three years to identify any potential issues.
  • Tax Liabilities: Assess any outstanding tax liabilities or disputes with tax authorities.
  • Tax Compliance: Ensure the business is compliant with all relevant tax laws and regulations, including, but not related to income, payroll and sales taxes.

3. How to Finance the Purchase

Self-Financing:

  • Savings: Use personal savings to finance the purchase. This option can reduce debt but may limit available capital for other uses.
  • Retirement Funds: Consider using retirement funds, such as a 401(k) or IRA, though this can come with risks and tax implications. I am not a huge fan of using retirement funds to finance a business due to risk but I have seen many clients use retirement funds successfully.

Debt Financing:

  • Bank Loans: Apply for a traditional bank loan. Ensure you have a strong business plan and financial projections. Look for smaller community banks and credit unions. I advise business buyers to stay away from the larger banks because in my experience those banks just don’t provide the same personal service on approvals.
  • SBA Loans: Consider loans backed by the Small Business Administration (SBA), which often offer favorable terms. Remember though you’ll probably need to provide a second mortgage on your home when using the SBA.
  • Seller Financing: Negotiate seller financing, where the seller provides a loan to the buyer. This can be a flexible and advantageous option, often with better terms than traditional bank loans. Seller financing can also show the seller’s confidence in the continued success of the business.

Equity Financing:

  • Investors: Seek out investors who are willing to provide capital in exchange for equity in the business.
  • Venture Capital: For businesses with high growth potential, venture capital can be an option.

4. Work with Professionals

Business Brokers:

  • Finding Opportunities: Brokers can help you find businesses that are for sale and match your criteria.
  • Negotiation: They can assist in negotiating the terms of the sale, although I think it’s better to engage your lawyer for those negotations.

Lawyers:

  • Legal Review: A business lawyer will review all legal documents and contracts to ensure your interests are protected. The business lawyer can also help with negotiations. Make sure you use a business lawyer. Don’t hire a friend who practices personal injury, divorce, criminal law, etc. Get a business law specialist to work with you.
  • Compliance: They ensure the transaction complies with all relevant laws and regulations.

Accountants:

  • Financial Review: An accountant will analyze the financial health of the business.
  • Tax Implications: They can advise on the tax implications of the purchase.

Bankers:

  • Financing Options: Bankers can provide information on financing options and help secure loans.
  • Financial Advice: They can offer financial advice tailored to your situation.

5. Finalize the Purchase Agreement

Purchase Agreement:

  • Terms and Conditions: Clearly outline the terms and conditions of the sale.
  • Assets Included: Specify which assets are included in the sale (inventory, equipment, intellectual property, etc.).
  • Price and Payment Terms: Detail the purchase price and payment terms.
  • Warranties and Representations: Include any warranties or representations made by the seller.
  • Non-Compete Clause: Consider including a non-compete clause to prevent the seller from starting a competing business. Make sure the non-compete is for at least a five (5) year period and covers a territory sufficient to protect your business.

Closing the Deal:

  • Due Diligence Completion: Ensure all due diligence is complete and satisfactory.
  • Financing Secured: Confirm that financing is secured and ready for disbursement.
  • Legal Documents Signed: Sign the purchase agreement and all necessary legal documents to finalize the transaction.

Buying an existing business is a significant investment and requires thorough preparation and professional guidance. By carefully evaluating the financial, market, and operational aspects, performing due diligence, securing financing, and working with experienced professionals, you can make a well-informed decision and increase your chances of success.

1721588395-2794-5126-lxb_photoP1Iz3unD6Polxb_photo-
Johannes Plenio, Unsplash

Thinking of diving into the world of franchising? Hold your horses! Before you jump in, it’s essential to do your homework. Here are seven must-do steps every savvy franchisee should follow to ensure they’re making a well-informed decision.

1. Review the Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD)

The FDD is your franchising bible. It’s packed with vital information about the franchise, including the business model, financial performance, and legal obligations. Take your time to read and understand every section. Trust me, it’s a long document but you need to understand it fully.

2. Consult with a Franchise Lawyer

Navigating the legal landscape of franchising can be tricky. That’s where a franchise lawyer comes in. They’ll help you decipher the legalese in the FDD and the franchise agreement, ensuring you’re fully aware of your rights and obligations. This step is important if you want to avoid nasty surprises down the road. And please, don’t go to your divorce lawyer (or even your typical business lawyer) to review the FDD. There are many details in franchising that are much different than ordinary business transactions. A franchise lawyer will understand these differences and be able to explain what you need to know.

3. Talk to Current Franchisees

Who better to give you the lowdown on the franchise than those who are already in the trenches? Reach out to current franchisees and ask them about their experiences—the good, the bad, and the ugly. Their insights can provide invaluable information about the day-to-day realities of running the franchise.

4. Engage in In-Depth Discussions with Franchisor Executives

Getting to know the people behind the franchise is crucial. Arrange meetings with the franchisor’s executives to discuss their vision, support systems, and future plans for the brand. This will give you a sense of their commitment to the franchise’s success and their willingness to support franchisees.

5. Develop a Solid Business Plan

A well-thought-out business plan is essential for any franchisee. Outline your goals, strategies, and financial projections. This plan will not only guide you but also demonstrate to the franchisor that you’re serious and prepared for the challenge ahead.

6. Analyze the Market and Competition

Conduct a thorough market analysis to understand your target audience and the competitive landscape. Knowing your market will help you tailor your business strategies and position your franchise for success. Remember to carefully consider the geographic area. What works in one area of the country may not necessarily work in another part of the country.

7. Evaluate Your Financial Position

Franchising requires a significant investment, so it’s crucial to assess your ability to invest. Determine how much capital you have, how much you can borrow, and what your return on investment might look like. Being financially prepared will help you weather the initial startup phase and set you up for long-term success.

Embarking on a franchise journey is exciting, but it’s also a big commitment. By taking these seven steps, you’ll be well on your way to making an informed decision and setting yourself up for a thriving franchising career.

Piggy bank
Andre Taissin, Unsplash

All over the Web, you’ll see countless posts on strategies and benefits of obtaining seller financing if you are buying a business. And while that’s great for a business buyer, there are different considerations if you are a business owner. If you are selling a business, the financial terms can significantly impact your future financial stability and peace of mind. Seller financing is a situation where the seller loans the buyer a portion of the purchase price to be paid back over time. While this might seem like a feasible way to close a deal quickly (and there are times where maybe you need to use it), securing upfront payment is often the more prudent choice for sellers. Here’s why:

1. Immediate Financial Security

One of the most compelling reasons to get your money upfront is the immediate financial security it provides. Selling a business is a significant financial milestone, and receiving the full payment ensures that you have the funds available to meet your personal and professional needs without delay.

2. Eliminating Payment Risk

Seller financing inherently carries the risk of default. Even if a buyer seems financially stable, unforeseen circumstances can lead to their inability to make future payments. This puts the seller in a precarious position, potentially having to take legal action or even repossess the business, which can be both costly and time-consuming.

3. Avoiding Interest and Inflation Concerns

When you finance a buyer, you typically charge interest on the outstanding balance. However, the interest rate might not always keep pace with inflation, eroding the real value of your money over time. Receiving the full payment upfront eliminates this risk, allowing you to invest or utilize the money in a manner that best suits your financial goals.

4. Simplifying Tax Implications

Receiving full payment upfront can simplify your tax situation. With seller financing, you may face complex tax implications related to installment sales, including tracking interest income and principal repayments over several years. An upfront payment allows you to manage your tax liabilities more straightforwardly and effectively.

5. Freedom to Move On

Once you’ve sold your business and received full payment, you’re free to move on to your next venture or retirement without being tethered to the success of the buyer. Seller financing ties your financial future to the new owner’s business performance, which can be stressful and limiting.

6. Strengthening Negotiating Position

Requesting full payment upfront can strengthen your negotiating position. It sends a clear message that you are confident in the value of your business and expect to be compensated accordingly. Serious buyers who recognize the worth of your business are more likely to agree to your terms.

7. Mitigating Legal and Operational Hassles

Seller financing often includes additional agreements and ongoing legal responsibilities. By opting for full payment upfront, you can avoid these potential hassles, allowing for a cleaner, more straightforward transaction.

Strategies for Securing Upfront Payment

To encourage buyers to pay upfront, consider these strategies:

  • Offer a Discount: Provide a small discount for buyers willing to pay the full amount upfront. This can be a compelling incentive. I know most sellers want the highest price but taking slightly less and getting all your payment up front may actually be more advantageous.
  • Highlight Financial Strength: Emphasize the financial stability and profitability of your business to assure buyers of its value.
  • Professional Valuation: Obtain a professional valuation to back up your asking price and justify the need for upfront payment.
  • Flexible Terms: While insisting on full payment, be open to negotiating other terms of the sale, such as transitional consulting support or training to sweeten the deal for the buyer.

Conclusion

While seller financing may seem like a convenient way to facilitate a sale, the risks and complexities often outweigh the benefits. Securing upfront payment provides immediate financial security, eliminates payment risk, simplifies tax implications, and allows you to move forward without ongoing obligations. By positioning yourself firmly but fairly in negotiations, you can achieve a sale that benefits both you and the buyer, ensuring a smooth and prosperous transition for all.

1720993545-2778-2474-lxb_photoKrPulSdUetklxb_photo-
Kaffeebart, Unsplash

When deciding how to structure your business, one crucial consideration is asset protection. A common belief is that corporations offer better asset protection than Limited Liability Companies (LLCs). However, this belief is a myth. LLCs can provide equally robust asset protection, often with greater flexibility and fewer formalities.

The Rise of the LLC

LLCs have gained widespread popularity in the United States, including in Iowa, due to their unique blend of liability protection, tax benefits, and operational flexibility. All states, including Iowa, have enacted laws that make LLCs a reliable option for business owners seeking asset protection.

Why the Myth Exists

The myth that corporations offer superior asset protection likely stems from the fact corporations have been around for so much longer. But even though that’s the case, both corporations and LLCs offer limited liability protection, meaning that the personal assets of the owners (shareholders in a corporation, members in an LLC) are generally shielded from business debts and legal claims. This protection is inherent in the structure of both entities.

Uniform Application of LLC Laws

In Iowa and across the United States, LLC laws have been standardized to provide uniform protection and governance. The Revised Uniform Limited Liability Company Act has been adopted by many states to ensure LLCs offer consistent legal protection and operational guidelines, reinforcing the credibility and reliability of LLCs as a business structure.

Importance of Corporate Formalities

Regardless of whether you choose a corporation or an LLC, adhering to corporate formalities is essential for maintaining asset protection. Failing to follow these formalities can result in the loss of limited liability protection, exposing personal assets to business liabilities.

Here are key practices to follow for both corporations and LLCs:

  1. Keep Documents in Order: Ensure that all formation documents, operating agreements, bylaws, and minutes of meetings are properly documented and maintained.
  2. Separate Personal and Business Finances: Use separate bank accounts for personal and business transactions. Commingling funds can lead to a court piercing the corporate veil, exposing personal assets to business liabilities.
  3. Make Necessary Filings with the State: Stay compliant with state requirements by filing annual reports and other necessary documents on time.

Conclusion

The belief that corporations offer better asset protection than LLCs is unfounded. LLCs provide effective protection when structured and managed correctly. The key to maintaining asset protection lies in adhering to the required formalities and keeping your business operations and finances well-documented and separate from personal matters. By doing so, you can ensure that your chosen business structure, whether a corporation or an LLC, offers the protection you need to safeguard your assets.

Shooting in my office
Tierra Mallorca, Unsplash

This is a question I get all the time. When managing multiple rental properties, one of the primary questions investors face is whether to establish a separate Limited Liability Company (LLC) for each property. While an LLC offers several advantages, the decision to create one for each property involves various considerations, such as the amount of equity in each property, the locations of the properties, associated costs, and whether the properties are in the same state. Here’s a closer look at each of these factors:

1. Equity in the Property

High Equity: If a property has significant equity, forming a separate LLC can safeguard that high equity property from other properties to reduce potential risk. Should a lawsuit arise with another property, having the property in a separate LLC can protect your the equity from being at risk.

Low Equity: For properties with low equity, the perceived need for having a separate LLC might be less. However, even with low equity, the property can still be subject to legal claims so grouping those low equity properties in a LLC is still preferable to holding the rental property in your personal name.

2. Property Location

Different Locations: When properties are in different states, forming separate LLCs might be prudent. This approach can help navigate varying state laws regarding real estate and liability. Each state has its own regulations and protections, and an LLC in one state may not offer the same benefits or recognition in another.

Same Location: If all properties are in the same state, a single LLC might suffice. However, this could increase liability, as legal issues with one property could potentially affect all properties under the same LLC.

3. Costs

Formation Costs: Establishing an LLC involves initial formation fees, which vary by state. For investors with multiple properties, creating separate LLCs for each property means multiple sets of fees.

Maintenance Costs: Beyond formation, maintaining an LLC includes annual fees, registered agent fees, and potential legal, accounting and insurance costs. These can add up quickly if multiple LLCs are involved.

4. State-Specific Considerations

State Laws: Each state may have different laws regarding LLCs and real estate. Understanding state-specific regulations is crucial. Always consult a business/real estate lawyer licensed to practice in that state.

Tax Implications: The tax implications of LLCs can vary by state. Some states impose higher taxes or fees on LLCs, which could influence the decision to form separate LLCs for each property.

Advantages of Separate LLCs

  1. Liability Protection: Each property is isolated from the others, reducing the risk of losing multiple properties in a single lawsuit.
  2. Simplified Accounting: Separate LLCs can simplify accounting and financial tracking, making it easier to manage income and expenses for each property.
  3. Clear Ownership Structure: For investors with partners, separate LLCs can provide a clear ownership structure for each property.

Disadvantages of Separate LLCs

  1. Increased Costs: Formation and maintenance costs multiply with each additional LLC.
  2. Administrative Burden: Managing multiple LLCs requires more administrative work, including separate bookkeeping, tax filings, and legal compliance.
  3. Complexity in Financing: Obtaining financing might be more complex, as lenders must deal with multiple LLCs which requires more paperwork, applications and loan approvals.

Conclusion

The decision to create a separate LLC for each rental property depends on your specific circumstances, including the equity in your properties, their locations, the associated costs, and the legal and tax implications in your state. Consulting with a business/real estate attorney and tax advisor can provide personalized advice based on your situation. Balancing liability protection with cost and administrative considerations is key to making an informed decision.

Ultimately, the right choice varies for each investor, and careful consideration of these factors will help you determine the best strategy for managing and protecting your rental property investments.

Business Franchise Street Sign
Business Franchise Street Sign

In the world of franchising, the franchise agreement is the cornerstone of the relationship between the franchisor and the franchisee. This legal document outlines the rights, responsibilities, and expectations of both parties. While many potential franchisees feel they must accept the agreement as presented (particulary since many franchisors claim it cannot be negotiated), one franchise client demonstrated the power of negotiation—and the willingness to walk away—resulting in several crucial concessions that set them up for success.

The Initial Approach

Our client, a savvy entrepreneur with a keen eye for opportunities, was interested in a franchise. The brand has a decent reputation, and initial discussions with the franchisor were promising. However, upon reviewing the FDD and franchise agreement, we identified several terms that could potentially impact their business adversely. Instead of immediately signing on the dotted line, they decided to take a strategic approach to negotiation.

Identifying Key Issues

The first step was to identify the non-negotiable elements versus the negotiable aspects of the agreement. The client focused on:

  1. Initial Franchise Fee: The upfront cost was steep, and our client believed there was room for adjustment.
  2. Royalty Fees: The royalty fees seemed higher than the average in the industry, but a real issue was a mandatory minimum sales/royalties amount after one year.
  3. Territorial Rights: The agreement provided only limited protection against encroachment by other franchisees, which could affect market share.
  4. Renewal Terms: The conditions for renewing the franchise agreement were vague and potentially unfavorable.
  5. Marketing Fees: The percentage of revenue allocated to a brand fund was high, and there was an extremely unfavorable provision for additional marketing costs in the event mandatory sales minimums were not met

The Power of Preparation

Preparation was key to the client’s negotiation strategy. We conducted thorough research, gathering information on industry standards, comparable franchise agreements, and the specific franchisor’s performance metrics. Armed with this information, the client was able to make a compelling case for each concession.

The Negotiation Process

Negotiations began with an open and honest discussion about the client’s concerns. They approached the franchisor with respect but also with clear demands. The client’s willingness to walk away from the deal if necessary played a crucial role. This stance demonstrated to the franchisor that they were dealing with a serious and knowledgeable potential franchisee partner.

  1. Initial Franchise Fee Reduction: The client presented data showing average franchise fees within the industry. After several rounds of discussion, the franchisor agreed to reduce the initial fee, making the investment more manageable.
  2. Royalty Fee Reduction: The client achieved a royalty fee reduction for a period of a couple years, but most importantly the mandatory minimum royalty/sales amount was eliminated for the duration of the franchise agreement.
  3. Enhanced Territorial Rights: The client argued that stronger territorial protection would benefit both parties by ensuring market stability. The franchisor agreed to amend the agreement, granting the client exclusive rights within a larger radius, thus preventing encroachment by new franchisees. We believe this is extremely important in our metro area where everyone is “fifteen minutes away!”
  4. Clearer Renewal Terms: The client insisted on more transparent and favorable renewal conditions. The franchisor provided a detailed outline of the renewal process, including clear criteria for performance.
  5. Marketing Fee Revisions: The franchisor eliminated the brand fund requirement for a period of time.

The Outcome

The willingness to negotiate and the readiness to walk away if necessary were pivotal in securing these concessions. The final agreement was not only more favorable to the client but also set a precedent for a more collaborative relationship with the franchisor. This empowers the client to operate their franchise with confidence, knowing they have a much better agreement that supports their business goals.

Lessons Learned

For prospective franchisees, this case underscores the importance of:

  1. Thoroughly Reviewing the Franchise Agreement: Understand every clause and its potential impact on your business.
  2. Conducting Comprehensive Research: Know the industry standards and how other franchises operate.
  3. Being Prepared to Negotiate: Approach the franchisor with respect but be clear about your needs and expectations.
  4. Demonstrating Willingness to Walk Away: This is a powerful leverage tool in negotiations.

Negotiating a franchise agreement can be difficult, but with the right approach, it is possible to secure terms that provide a solid foundation for your franchise business. This client’s success story is a testament to the power of strategic negotiation and the courage to advocate for oneself in the franchise world.

Just a sudden attempt to express the concept of crime.
niu niu, Unsplash

In the realm of business agreements, noncompete clauses have long been a subject of scrutiny and debate. These contractual provisions restrict individuals from working for or starting a competing business within a specified time frame and geographical area after leaving their current employment. While the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has taken steps to limit the application of noncompetes with its recent ban, one area where they still hold sway is in the franchise industry.

Franchise Noncompetes: An Exception to the Rule

Despite the FTC’s efforts to limit the scope of noncompete agreements, one area where these clauses remain prevalent is within franchise agreements. Franchisors often include noncompete provisions in their contracts with franchisees to protect their brand, goodwill, and proprietary business methods.

Unlike in the realm of traditional employment contracts, where the FTC’s noncompete ban holds sway, franchise noncompetes are not included in these restrictions. This exemption is based on the rationale that franchise agreements involve a different set of considerations than typical employment relationships. Franchisees invest substantial resources into establishing and operating their businesses under the franchisor’s brand, and noncompete clauses serve to protect the franchisor’s investment in the franchise system as a whole.

Navigating Franchise Noncompetes: Considerations for Franchisees

For aspiring entrepreneurs considering entering into a franchise agreement, understanding the implications of the included noncompete clause is crucial. Here are some key considerations:

  1. Scope and Duration: Pay close attention to the scope and duration of the noncompete clause. Ensure that the restrictions imposed are reasonable and necessary to protect the legitimate interests of the franchisor.
  2. Geographical Limitations: The noncompete clause should specify the geographic area within which the franchisee is prohibited from competing. Ensure that these limitations are tailored to the specific market served by the franchise and do not unduly restrict future business opportunities.
  3. Legal Review: Before signing any franchise agreement, it’s advisable to seek legal counsel to review the terms and conditions, including the noncompete clause. A qualified attorney can help assess the enforceability of the provision and negotiate any necessary modifications.
  4. Alternative Options: In rare cases, franchisees may be able to negotiate the removal or modification of the noncompete clause altogether. Alternatively, they may explore franchise opportunities with less restrictive noncompete provisions or consider independent business ventures that offer greater flexibility.

Conclusion

While the FTC’s ban on noncompete clauses in employment contracts represents a significant step towards promoting competition and worker mobility, it’s important to recognize that franchise agreements operate within a different legal framework. Franchise noncompetes remain a common feature of these contracts, designed to protect the interests of both franchisors and franchisees. Aspiring franchisees should carefully review and consider the implications of these clauses before committing to a franchise opportunity, seeking legal guidance as needed to ensure a clear understanding of their rights and obligations.